Risks for (inexpensive) classic pearls
11/30/2022
Long-time Zwischengas readers may remember the article in which we promoted the Mini Cooper Clubman (R55) to classic pearl status .
In the meantime, we have gained some experience with it and we are no longer so optimistic that many examples will even make it to classic car age.
Back in 2020, our little car came close to being a total write-off when the camshaft control unit gave up the ghost. But that wasn't the last major damage: later on, the catalytic converter also had to be replaced, a suspension coil spring broke and a lambda sensor had to be replaced. The fact that the gearshift knob also fell apart is something of a curiosity.
All in all, we spent considerably more on maintenance in three years than the car had cost when it was 12 years old. And this is probably no exception. Of course, some things could be repaired more cheaply, but the dealership quoted around three grand for a possible clutch replacement, for example.
Many parts that should actually last the life of the car give up the ghost relatively early on. Today, most spare parts are still reasonably easy to find, but in five or 15 years' time this will become increasingly difficult, even for a premium Mini.
All this does not mean that the full costs for such a car are excessively high, because in view of the fact that the Mini now has over 180,000 km on the clock, the maintenance costs are actually bearable, also because the depreciation is also low.
In total, the Mini has covered over 43,800 km including fuel/fluids/insurance/etc. and cost over CHF 22,000, i.e. just over CHF 0.50 per kilometer. With a few optimizations, we could certainly have saved a few more centimes per kilometer. It's still not cheap to drive a Mini, but we know that today.
But now back to the subject: expensive repairs and parts that give up the ghost too early, electronic complexity and sometimes difficult fault diagnoses make the long phase until a young car becomes a real classic and vintage car a risky trip. In any case, the Mini photographed will probably never become a classic car ...